Search and Paid Ads: The Arithmetic Before You Spend
Learn the difference between organic and paid search, work out CPC, conversion, CPA and break-even with a worked example, and see why quality can beat a higher bid in a simple model.
In this lesson you will
- Tell organic and paid results apart
- Work out CPC, conversion rate and CPA
- Find a break-even cost per click
- Check the numbers before spending
About 24 minutes
Noor tries a 300 pound advert
Noor has a little spare money and wants customers faster than posting allows. She puts 300 pounds into search ads, which show a small advert when someone types a related search. She watches the clicks arrive and feels pleased. At the end of the month she checks her sales and finds that she has spent more than she earned. The advert worked, in that people clicked. The arithmetic did not. This lesson explains how search results and ads differ, how the key numbers are worked out, and how to tell before you spend whether an advert can pay for itself.
Two ways to appear in search
- Organic results. Pages that a search engine decides are helpful. You do not pay per click, but it takes time and good content. The free SEO course on this site goes much deeper.
- Paid results. Ads that you pay for each time someone clicks, called pay per click or PPC. They can start working within hours and stop the day you stop paying.
Google’s help pages describe a search ad auction that runs each time someone searches. Who appears, and where, depends on your bid and also on the quality of the ad and the page it leads to, as measured at that moment, including things like how relevant the ad is and the landing page experience. You usually pay no more than your maximum bid, and better quality can mean a better position at a lower cost. The detail changes, so read the current help pages on any platform before you spend. Other ad platforms work in similar ways but not identically.
The numbers that matter
- Cost per click (CPC). What you pay when someone clicks.
- Conversion rate. The share of clickers who buy.
- Cost per acquisition (CPA). What each order cost you in advertising: budget divided by orders.
- Margin. What you keep from each order after the product and delivery costs, before advertising.
The rule is simple: if your CPA is higher than your margin, you lose money on each order. The program below uses made-up pounds. It also includes a deliberately simplified auction model, with a bid and a quality score for three shops, to show why the highest bid does not always win. The model is a teaching toy and is not Google’s real formula.
# MADE-UP search-ad numbers, in pounds
budget, cpc, conv, margin = 300, 0.60, 0.03, 14.00
clicks = budget / cpc
orders = clicks * conv
cpa = budget / orders
print("clicks:", round(clicks))
print("orders:", round(orders, 1))
print("cost per order:", round(cpa, 2))
print("profit per order:", round(margin - cpa, 2))
print("total profit:", round(orders * margin - budget, 2))
print("break-even cost per click:", round(margin * conv, 2))
better = 0.05
o2 = budget / cpc * better
print("at 5% conversion, orders:", round(o2, 1))
print("at 5% conversion, profit:", round(o2 * margin - budget, 2))
# a simplified teaching model of an ad auction (NOT Google's real formula)
ads = {"Shop A": (1.00, 4), "Shop B": (0.70, 8), "Shop C": (0.90, 5)}
rank = {n: b * q for n, (b, q) in ads.items()}
for n in sorted(rank, key=rank.get, reverse=True):
print(f"{n}: bid {ads[n][0]:.2f} x quality {ads[n][1]} = {rank[n]:.1f}")
print("top spot:", max(rank, key=rank.get))
print("highest bid:", max(ads, key=lambda n: ads[n][0]))
clicks: 500
orders: 15.0
cost per order: 20.0
profit per order: -6.0
total profit: -90.0
break-even cost per click: 0.42
at 5% conversion, orders: 25.0
at 5% conversion, profit: 50.0
Shop B: bid 0.70 x quality 8 = 5.6
Shop C: bid 0.90 x quality 5 = 4.5
Shop A: bid 1.00 x quality 4 = 4.0
top spot: Shop B
highest bid: Shop A
A 300 pound budget at 0.60 per click buys 500 clicks. At a 3 per cent conversion rate that is 15.0 orders, so each order cost 20.0 pounds of advertising. But each order only leaves a margin of 14 pounds, so every order loses 6.0 pounds and the month loses 90.0. The break-even cost per click is 0.42 pounds: if clicks cost more than margin times conversion rate, the advert cannot pay. Here is the hopeful part. Raise the conversion rate to 5 per cent, perhaps by improving the page, and the same budget gives 25.0 orders and a 50.0 pound profit. The advert is the same, and the page changed the result. In the toy auction, Shop B bids the least yet takes the top spot because its quality is high, while the highest bidder, Shop A, comes last.
Before you spend
- Work out your margin per order honestly, including delivery and fees.
- Estimate your conversion rate from your own site, not from a number you read.
- Compute the break-even cost per click. If the price of clicks in your market is above it, fix the page first.
- Start with a small test budget and a clear stop point.
- Send the clicks to a page built for that advert, and track them with tagged links (lesson 9).
Treating clicks as success. Clicks cost money. Only orders, or another real goal, pay for them. Judge every advert by cost per order against your margin.
Ad platforms change their rules, tools and names often, and some topics and claims are restricted. Read the platform’s current policies and help pages before you launch, and never quote another person’s costs as if they were yours.
Practice for this lesson
Check what you learned
Five quick questions. Pick an answer and you will see straight away whether it is right and why.
What is CPA?
- Cost per post
- Clicks per advert
- What each order cost in advertising
- A profit measure
Budget divided by orders gives cost per acquisition.
When does an advert lose money on each order?
- When CPA is above the margin
- When CPC is low
- When clicks are many
- When it is a search ad
If the advertising cost per order exceeds what you keep, you lose.
How is break-even cost per click found?
- Budget divided by days
- Orders divided by clicks
- Margin times conversion rate
- Margin divided by budget
A click is worth margin times the chance it buys.
What can change an advert’s result without changing the ad?
- A better landing page
- A new month
- A bigger font
- A different logo
A higher conversion rate lowers cost per order.
Why can a lower bid win in the toy auction?
- Lower bids always win
- Quality multiplies the bid
- Bids are ignored
- It is random
In the model, rank combines bid and quality.
Summary
- Paid search charges per click; organic does not but takes time.
- CPA must be below margin for an advert to pay.
- Break-even CPC is margin times conversion rate.
- Fix the page before you raise the budget.
Questions
Is the auction model real?
No. It is a simplified teaching toy. Google describes ad quality as part of how ads are ranked, but the real system uses more factors and changes. Read the platform's own help pages.
How much should I spend on ads?
Only what you can afford to lose while you test, and with a clear stop point. First check that your page and margin can support paid clicks.
Are the figures real?
No. They are made-up sample numbers in pounds. Use your own margin and rates.
