IntermediateLesson 15 of 206 min read

Comments and Community: A Reply Routine and Moderation in Outline

Sort comments by hand and by simple rules, set a short reply routine, and use blocked words, held comments and moderators.

In this lesson you will

  • Sort comments into useful groups
  • Check a rule-based sorter against a person
  • Describe the main moderation settings
  • Set a weekly reply routine

About 28 minutes

Fifty comments and one evening

The basil videos are doing well, and the comments are piling up. Some are warm. Some ask real questions. Some are junk with links. Kofi opens Studio on a tired Thursday and does not know where to start, so he replies to the three nicest ones and closes the laptop. Two real questions wait a week. A good comment routine turns a pile into a short, repeatable job, and a few moderation settings make the pile smaller before you see it.

Why replies matter

A comment section is where viewers decide whether a person is behind the channel. A prompt, helpful reply to a question shows other viewers that questions are welcome. It also tells you what to make next, because the commonest questions in the comments are the best ideas for new videos. There is no formula that says replies will raise your numbers, and this course does not claim one. The case for replying is about people: it is polite, it builds trust, and it feeds your idea bank.

Sorting by hand, then with rules

The program uses 21 made-up comments, each with a label chosen by a person: a question, praise, spam or something else. A simple rule-based sorter then guesses the label from the text, as in the data analysis course: links and certain phrases mean spam, a question mark or an opening question word means a question, and warm words mean praise. The program compares the sorter’s guess with the person’s label.

comments = [
    ("how do I know if the pot is too big?", "question"), ("love this, so clear", "praise"), ("subscribe to my channel http://x.example", "spam"),
    ("what soil do you use?", "question"), ("thanks, my basil is alive again", "praise"), ("great tip about pinching", "praise"),
    ("win a prize at http://y.example now", "spam"), ("can I do this with mint?", "question"), ("first", "other"),
    ("my plant is on a north window, any idea?", "question"), ("so helpful, thank you", "praise"), ("check my page for free followers", "spam"),
    ("did you water before filming", "question"), ("nice balcony", "praise"), ("music is a bit loud", "other"),
    ("how often should I water in winter", "question"), ("brilliant video", "praise"), ("sub for sub?", "spam"),
    ("any idea what to do about aphids", "question"), ("love it but where is that pot from", "question"), ("visit my page for gifts", "spam"),
]
def guess(text):
    t = text.lower()
    if "http" in t or "sub for sub" in t or "free followers" in t:
        return "spam"
    if "?" in t or t.startswith(("how ", "what ", "can ", "did ")):
        return "question"
    if any(w in t for w in ("love", "thanks", "thank", "great", "nice", "brilliant", "helpful")):
        return "praise"
    return "other"
right = 0
for text, truth in comments:
    g = guess(text)
    right += g == truth
    if g != truth:
        print("miss: " + g + " vs " + truth + " | " + text)
print("agree:", right, "of", len(comments))
counts = {}
for text, truth in comments:
    counts[truth] = counts.get(truth, 0) + 1
print("by human label:", counts)
minutes_each = 2
questions = counts["question"]
print("reply time for questions:", questions * minutes_each, "minutes")
blocked = ["free followers", "sub for sub", "prize"]
held = [text for text, _ in comments if any(w in text.lower() for w in blocked) or "http" in text.lower()]
print("held for review by words and links:", len(held))
miss: other vs question | any idea what to do about aphids
miss: praise vs question | love it but where is that pot from
miss: other vs spam | visit my page for gifts
agree: 18 of 21
by human label: {'question': 8, 'praise': 6, 'spam': 5, 'other': 2}
reply time for questions: 16 minutes
held for review by words and links: 4

The rules agree with the person on 18 of 21 comments. The three misses show where simple rules fail. Any idea what to do about aphids is a question with no question mark. Love it but where is that pot from mixes praise with a question and is labelled by the first word that matches. And visit my page for gifts is spam with none of the words on the list. Real spam changes its wording all the time, which is why a short list will always fall behind.

By the human labels, there are 8 questions, 6 pieces of praise, 5 spam comments and 2 others. At two minutes for each question, the questions take 16 minutes to answer. That is the whole reply job for the batch. A job that looks like an evening turns out to be a quarter of an hour, once the spam is out of the way.

Moderation settings, in outline

YouTube Studio has settings to reduce the pile before you see it. At the time of writing, YouTube Help describes these:

  • Blocked words. Comments that contain words or phrases you list are held for review, and so are live chat messages.
  • Held for review. You can choose a level for holding comments that look inappropriate, from basic to strict, or hold all comments. Held comments wait in a queue for you, and Help says they stay there for up to 60 days.
  • Links. You can hold comments that contain web addresses, which catches a lot of spam. Comments from you, your moderators and approved users are not held.
  • Moderators. You can invite other people to help review comments. Help describes a standard and a managing moderator, and says moderators do not get access to your Studio.

The last line of the program applies a simple version of blocked words and links to the 21 comments. It holds 4, which includes the spam that carried a link or a listed phrase, and it still misses the gifts message. A filter is a net with holes, so look at the held queue now and then, because a good comment can be caught by mistake.

A weekly routine

  1. Choose a time. Twenty or thirty minutes, twice a week, is easier than a daily scroll.
  2. Clear the held queue first. Approve the good, remove the junk.
  3. Answer questions before praise. A thank-you to praise can be short.
  4. Note repeated questions in your idea bank, with a count.
  5. Do not argue. Answer a rude comment once, politely, or do not answer. You can remove comments that break your rules.
Common mistake: feast and famine

Replying to nothing for weeks and then answering everything at once at midnight. Short, regular sessions are kinder to you and better for viewers.

Made-up comments

The comments, labels and word lists are made up. Moderation menus and settings change, so check YouTube Help for the latest wording before relying on a setting.

Write the three questions you are asked most often by people about your topic. They are your next three videos.

Practice for this lesson

Check what you learned

Five quick questions. Pick an answer and you will see straight away whether it is right and why.

Why keep a comment routine?

  1. It raises views by a formula
  2. It is required by the site
  3. It turns a pile into a short, repeatable job
  4. It removes the need to read comments

The case is about people and ideas, not a formula.

What does a held comment mean in Studio?

  1. It waits in a queue until you approve or remove it
  2. It is published at once
  3. It is deleted for ever
  4. It is sent to the viewer

Help says held comments stay for a limited time.

Why will a short list of spam words always fall behind?

  1. Lists are illegal
  2. Spammers change their wording
  3. Spam never uses words
  4. Lists cannot hold words

The sorter missed a spam comment with no listed word.

What do moderators get, according to YouTube Help?

  1. They get full control of the channel
  2. They can see earnings
  3. They can delete the channel
  4. They help review comments but do not get access to your Studio

Give each helper the narrowest role.

What should you do with repeated questions?

  1. Delete them
  2. Note them as ideas for new videos
  3. Ignore them
  4. Answer them with spam

Common questions are the best ideas.

Summary

  • Replies build trust and feed your idea bank.
  • Rules miss tricky comments, so check them against a person.
  • Blocked words, links and held comments reduce the pile.
  • A short, regular routine beats a midnight marathon.

Next lesson

Lesson 16 makes videos easier to follow with captions and subtitles.

Questions

Should I reply to every comment?

Not necessarily. Answer questions first, thank a few kind comments, and do not feel pressed to answer every one. Your time is limited, and the routine should be one you can keep.

Is it safe to turn comments off?

You may. It is your choice, and some creators do for particular videos. The cost is that you lose questions and ideas, so many prefer to filter and hold instead.

What if someone is abusive?

You do not owe them a reply. You can remove the comment, hide the user from your channel, or hold such comments for review. If it is serious or threatening, report it through the site's tools and consider telling someone you trust.

Progress is saved in this browser.