Shorts and Long Videos: How the Site Tells Them Apart and What Each Costs
See how a file is classed as a Short, compare the effort of both formats with real arithmetic, and choose by idea, viewer and capacity.
In this lesson you will
- Say how a file counts as a Short
- Check boundary cases of the rule
- Compare effort of the two formats
- Choose a format for an idea
About 26 minutes
Short or long?
Abena tells Kofi that everyone is making Shorts, and he should too. Kofi is not sure what a Short is. Is it a different kind of account? A different app? A hashtag? It is none of those. Choosing between short videos and long ones is one of the first practical decisions of a channel, and it is easier once you know how the site decides which is which, and what each kind costs you in time.
What counts as a Short
A Short is a short, upright or square video. At the time of writing, YouTube Help says that a video that is square or vertical and up to three minutes long is treated as a Short. Until October 2024, the limit was sixty seconds, and many websites still show the old number, so always check YouTube Help for the current rule. Two conditions must both be true: the shape and the length. A wide video of any length is a regular video, and a long upright one is a regular video too. The site classifies the file by its size and duration. You do not tick a box, and a hashtag does not decide.
def kind(width, height, seconds):
vertical_or_square = height >= width
return "Short" if vertical_or_square and seconds <= 180 else "regular video"
files = [(1080, 1920, 45), (1080, 1080, 170), (1920, 1080, 50), (1080, 1920, 200), (1080, 1920, 180), (1080, 1920, 181)]
for w, h, s in files:
print(str(w) + "x" + str(h) + ", " + str(s) + " s: " + kind(w, h, s))
formats = {
"Short": {"hours": 2.0, "finished_seconds": 45, "views": 900},
"long video": {"hours": 9.0, "finished_seconds": 480, "views": 600},
}
for name, f in formats.items():
per_hour = f["views"] / f["hours"]
per_minute = f["hours"] / (f["finished_seconds"] / 60)
print(name + ": " + str(round(per_hour)) + " views per work hour, " + str(round(per_minute, 1)) + " work hours per finished minute")
print("made-up numbers: not a forecast")
1080x1920, 45 s: Short
1080x1080, 170 s: Short
1920x1080, 50 s: regular video
1080x1920, 200 s: regular video
1080x1920, 180 s: Short
1080x1920, 181 s: regular video
Short: 450 views per work hour, 2.7 work hours per finished minute
long video: 67 views per work hour, 1.1 work hours per finished minute
made-up numbers: not a forecast
The program applies the rule to six made-up files. The first, 1080 by 1920 and 45 seconds, is a Short. The square one of 170 seconds is a Short too. The wide 50-second file is a regular video, because it is wide, however short. The upright 200-second file is a regular video, because it is too long. Look at the boundary: 180 seconds exactly is a Short, and one second more, 181, is not. Boundaries are where mistakes hide, which is why the lesson shows them.
Different formats, different effort
Now compare what the formats cost. The program uses made-up numbers for two kinds of video. A Short takes two hours of work for 45 seconds of finished video and gets 900 views. A long video takes nine hours for eight minutes and gets 600 views. Per hour of work, the Short brings 450 views against 67 for the long video. But per finished minute, the Short costs 2.7 work hours and the long video only 1.1. Both are true, and they pull in opposite directions.
What do the numbers mean? Not that Shorts are better, or that long videos are. They say that a Short is cheap to make as a whole but expensive for each second of finished video, and it is quick to try. A long video is slower to start, and it holds the depth that a three-minute limit cannot. The made-up views are not a forecast. Real views depend on the topic, the title, the audience and plain luck, and they differ wildly.
How to choose
- What does the idea need? A quick tip, a before and after or a single trick suits a Short. A step-by-step lesson suits a long video.
- Where is your viewer? People scrolling a phone see Shorts. People searching for help often open longer videos.
- What can you keep up? Two Shorts a week is possible for one person. Two long videos a week usually is not, as lesson 9 shows with numbers.
- Can one idea make both? A long video can yield a few short clips, and a Short can point to a longer video that goes deeper.
The two formats can also feed each other. Someone who sees a Short may look for the full video, and someone who liked a full video may enjoy short tips. Neither is guaranteed, and it is better to try each for a few weeks and look at the evidence in your own analytics, as the next lesson shows, than to follow what a stranger said online.
Things to watch out for
- The old rules online. Many articles still say sixty seconds. Look at YouTube Help for the date and the wording.
- Black bars. A wide video put into a tall frame, or the reverse, is a sign that you filmed in the wrong shape.
- Reusing material you do not own. The same copyright care applies to short videos, as lesson 9 covers.
Believing that a hashtag or a button makes a Short. The site goes by the shape and length of the file. Film it upright, check the length, and then upload.
The files, hours and views are made up. The classification rule is as documented at the time of writing and may change. Check YouTube Help before relying on a number.
Practice for this lesson
Check what you learned
Five quick questions. Pick an answer and you will see straight away whether it is right and why.
Which two conditions must both be true for a Short, as documented at the time of writing?
- A hashtag and a title
- Wide and short
- Square or vertical, and within the length limit
- A thumbnail and chapters
The site goes by the file’s shape and length.
Is a wide video of 50 seconds a Short?
- No, because it is wide
- Yes, because it is short
- Only with a hashtag
- Only on a phone
Both conditions must hold.
Why does the lesson test 180 and 181 seconds?
- They are random
- They are two shapes
- Boundaries are where mistakes hide
- They are file sizes
180 was a Short and 181 was not under the rule shown.
What do the effort numbers show about Shorts?
- Cheap as a whole, but costly for each finished minute
- They always get more views
- They are always better
- They need no editing
Both comparisons are true and they pull in opposite directions.
Where should you look for the current Shorts rule?
- An old article
- YouTube Help
- A video thumbnail
- Your channel name
Old numbers survive on many websites.
Summary
- A Short is square or vertical and within a length limit; check Help for the current number.
- The site goes by file shape and length, not hashtags.
- Shorts are quick to try but costly per finished minute.
- Choose by idea, viewer and what you can keep up.
Questions
Should I start with Shorts or long videos?
Start with whichever suits your first idea and what you can finish. It is fine to try both for a month and compare, provided you do not read too much into very small numbers.
Can I upload a wide video as a Short?
Not as the site defines a Short at the time of writing. You would need to reframe it into an upright or square shape. Check the Help pages for the current guidance.
Do Shorts and long videos count differently?
They have different places to be shown and different analytics. Read the Help pages and your own numbers, and avoid comparing a Short and a long video as if they were the same.
