Case Studies and Honest Authority
Write honest case studies: include a problem, action, measured before and after and permission, check every claim against the numbers and build authority without exaggeration.
In this lesson you will
- List what a case study contains
- Check claims against numbers
- Get permission and avoid exaggeration
- Use case studies in your marketing
About 24 minutes
A prospective client asks, “What results have you had?”
A bakery owner is thinking about hiring Dev and asks what results Dev has delivered for others. Dev has one good story, the cafe job, but only has a vague answer. A case study is a short, honest account of a past job: who the client was, what the problem was, what you did and what changed. It is the most persuasive thing a new freelancer can show, because it is specific. It is also easy to get wrong in ways that hurt your reputation. This lesson covers how to write one that is true, useful and permitted.
What a good case study contains
- The client, named with permission or described generally.
- The problem, in plain terms.
- What you did, briefly.
- The result, with a before and an after.
- How it was measured, so a reader can trust the numbers.
- A quote from the client, if they are happy to give one.
Keep it short, around a page. Use real numbers wherever you have them, and plain words where you do not.
Check it with a program
The program below holds Dev’s made-up cafe case study as a set of fields. It checks which required fields are missing, works out the change from before to after, and tests three possible claims against the real numbers. It also notices that no client quote has been collected yet. Every claim in a case study should survive a check like this one.
# MADE-UP case study notes for a proofreading job
case = {
"client": "Cafe Sol",
"problem": "14 typos on the menu pages",
"action": "proofread 8 pages and wrote a style sheet",
"before": 14,
"after": 1,
"how counted": "counted typos on the live pages before and one month after",
"permission": True,
"quote": "",
}
need = ["client", "problem", "action", "before", "after", "how counted", "permission"]
missing = [k for k in need if case[k] in ("", None, False)]
print("fields missing:", missing)
change = (case["before"] - case["after"]) / case["before"]
print("fewer typos:", f"{change:.0%}")
print("typos removed:", case["before"] - case["after"])
claims = [("93% fewer typos", 0.93), ("no typos at all", 1.0), ("half the typos", 0.5)]
for text, value in claims:
gap = abs(value - change)
print(f"{text}: {'supported' if gap < 0.01 else 'not supported'}")
print("quote from client:", "none yet" if not case["quote"] else case["quote"])
fields missing: []
fewer typos: 93%
typos removed: 13
93% fewer typos: supported
no typos at all: not supported
half the typos: not supported
quote from client: none yet
Missing fields: []. All seven are filled, including permission, which is the one people forget. The cafe had 14 typos before and 1 after, so the change is 93 per cent fewer, which is 13 typos removed. Now the claims. ‘93% fewer typos’ is supported, because it matches the real figure. ‘No typos at all’ is not supported, because one typo remained, and writing it would be a small lie that a careful reader could catch. ‘Half the typos’ is also not supported, since it understates the result, which is as wrong as overstating it. The last line shows that no client quote has been collected yet: none yet. A quote makes a case study more convincing, but only if the client really said it and agrees to its use.
Rules for honest case studies
- Get permission. Ask before naming a client, using their words, logo or figures. Confidential work stays confidential.
- Use real numbers. Never invent or round up results. Say ‘about’ where you are estimating.
- Say what you did. Do not take credit for what the client or others did.
- Show the method. How were the numbers counted, and over what period?
- Do not promise the same result. Say that results vary with the client and situation.
- Update or retire old ones. A case study from five years ago may no longer be true.
If you have no results yet
Beginners often have no case studies. You can create honest ones with a small project: help a friend, a club or a charity, agree in advance that you may describe it, count something before and after, and write it up. Label it clearly as a small project. A modest, true story is far better than a big, vague one. Another route is a ‘before and after’ sample on a real public page, with the owner’s permission.
Where to use them
- Put your best case study on your main page, with its numbers near the top.
- Add a short version to every proposal where it fits.
- Use the client’s quote, with permission, in your profile.
- Share the lessons you learned in a short post, which also builds authority.
- Collect a number and a quote at the end of every job, while the client is happy.
Authority is slow and honest
Authority means that people believe you know your subject. It grows from small true things repeated: case studies, helpful posts, replies in communities and steady work. It cannot be bought, and it is easily lost by a single exaggeration. Be the person whose numbers always check out.
Rounding a result up to sound better, such as ‘no typos’ for ‘one typo’. A reader who finds the one will doubt everything else you say. State the true number and let it speak.
The case study, counts and claims are made up. Advertising and testimonial rules differ by country, and using a client’s name, words or figures may need their permission. This lesson is an outline and not legal advice.
Practice for this lesson
Check what you learned
Five quick questions. Pick an answer and you will see straight away whether it is right and why.
What is a case study?
- A price list
- A short honest account of a past job and its result
- A contract
- A social post
It shows who, what, how and the result.
Why was “no typos at all” not supported?
- It was too long
- It lacked a quote
- It had no date
- One typo remained
Overstating results is a small lie.
Why was “half the typos” also rejected?
- It was rude
- It understated the real result
- It was illegal
- It was long
Claims should match the true number in both directions.
What must you get before naming a client?
- A discount
- A review
- A logo
- Permission
Using names, words or figures needs agreement.
What can a beginner with no results do?
- Make an honest small project and measure it
- Invent a case study
- Copy one
- Wait for years
A modest, true project is better than a vague big claim.
Summary
- A case study states the problem, action, result, method and permission.
- Check every claim against the real numbers.
- Understating is as wrong as overstating.
- Authority grows from small true things repeated.
Questions
Do I need a client's name in a case study?
No. You can describe the client generally, such as "a local cafe", if they prefer. Ask permission before using any name, quote or figure.
What if the results were small?
Say so honestly. A small, true result with a clear method is more believable than a big claim.
Can I use a case study from a previous employer?
Only with their permission, and many employers do not allow it. When unsure, create a new sample instead.
