IntermediateLesson 19 of 305 min read

Platforms Versus Direct Work

Compare a platform job with a direct client by net pay per hour, including search time, see when direct work wins over repeat jobs and learn which questions to ask any platform.

In this lesson you will

  • Compare sources by net pay per hour
  • Include search time in the sum
  • See when direct work wins
  • Ask the right questions of platforms

About 23 minutes

A platform job has arrived, and so has a direct one

Dev gets two offers for the same sort of 12-hour job paying 300. One comes through a freelance platform, where the client found Dev. The other comes from a bakery Dev wrote to directly. Which is better? Most people say the direct one, because ‘platforms take a fee’. But the fee is only one part of the sum. The time it took to find each client counts too. This lesson shows how to compare them honestly, using made-up numbers, and how to think about using both.

What platforms offer and what they cost

  • Clients come to you, or you can apply to many jobs in one place.
  • Some protection. Many platforms hold payment or offer dispute help. Check what each one really offers.
  • A fee. Platforms usually take a share of what you earn, and some charge in other ways. Fees and rules differ and change, so read each platform’s current terms. None are quoted in this course.
  • Competition. Many other freelancers see the same jobs.
  • Rules. Some platforms limit contact outside the platform or moving clients elsewhere. Read the terms before you try.

Compare net pay per hour

Count everything: the money you keep and all the hours, including the hours spent finding the job. The program below uses a made-up platform fee of 10 per cent and a payment cost of 3 per cent, which applies either way. It assumes that the platform job needed 2 hours of searching and applying, and the direct job needed 5 hours of outreach.

# MADE-UP numbers; fees differ by platform and change, so these are examples only
gross, work_hours = 300, 12
platform_fee, payment_cost = 0.10, 0.03
search_platform, search_direct = 2.0, 5.0

net_platform = gross * (1 - platform_fee - payment_cost)
net_direct = gross * (1 - payment_cost)
print(f"platform: {net_platform:.2f} net, {net_platform / (work_hours + search_platform):.2f} an hour")
print(f"direct: {net_direct:.2f} net, {net_direct / (work_hours + search_direct):.2f} an hour")

per_direct = net_direct / (work_hours + search_direct)
equal_fee = 1 - payment_cost - per_direct * (work_hours + search_platform) / gross
print(f"fee that makes them equal: {equal_fee:.1%}")

second = 2 * net_direct / (2 * work_hours + search_direct)
print(f"direct, second job for the same client: {second:.2f} an hour")
gap = second - net_platform / (work_hours + search_platform)
print(f"gap in favour of direct after two jobs: {gap:.2f}")
platform: 261.00 net, 18.64 an hour
direct: 291.00 net, 17.12 an hour
fee that makes them equal: 17.1%
direct, second job for the same client: 20.07 an hour
gap in favour of direct after two jobs: 1.43

On the platform, Dev keeps 261.00 after fees and earns 18.64 an hour over 14 hours. Direct, Dev keeps 291.00 but spends 17 hours in all, which gives 17.12 an hour. So the platform wins on the first job, even though it takes a fee. The fee at which both would be equal is 17.1 per cent, which is far above the 10 per cent assumed. The time saved is worth more than the fee.

Now the twist. A direct client can come back without any searching. If the bakery hires Dev again for a second similar job, the search cost is already paid. Over two jobs, the direct client gives 20.07 an hour, which is 1.43 more than the platform. The direct route needs patience, since it pays off over repeat work, and the platform pays off at once. Neither is always better. It depends on your fee, your search time and how often clients return.

A sensible mix

  • Use a platform to find first clients and build samples and reviews.
  • Do such good work that clients want to return, and follow each platform’s rules about doing so.
  • Invest steady hours in direct outreach, as in lesson 12, so that you do not depend on one place.
  • Track your own hours and fees for each source, as in lesson 3, and compare yearly.
  • Never depend on a single platform for all your income. Rules and fees can change.

Questions to ask about any platform

  1. What is the total fee on my earnings, and when do I pay it?
  2. How and when am I paid, and what protects me if a client does not pay?
  3. What do the rules say about contacting clients outside the platform?
  4. How are disputes handled, and what happens to my reviews?
  5. What happens to my profile if I stop using it?
Common mistake: looking only at the fee

Judging a source by its fee alone. A zero-fee source that takes ten hours to produce one client may pay less per hour than a source with a fee that produces clients in two. Count the time.

Sample data and not advice

The fee, the search hours and the job price are made up in sample money, and real platforms differ and change. No platform fees are quoted here, so read each platform’s current terms. This lesson is an outline and not financial or legal advice.

Choose two sources of clients you use. Estimate the hours spent finding a job on each, subtract fees and divide the net by all hours. Which pays better per hour?

Practice for this lesson

Check what you learned

Five quick questions. Pick an answer and you will see straight away whether it is right and why.

Why count the time spent finding the job?

  1. It is free
  2. It is tax
  3. It is illegal
  4. It is a real cost that lowers your pay per hour

Hours spent finding work reduce your effective rate.

Which route paid more per hour on the first job?

  1. The direct client
  2. The platform
  3. They tied
  4. Neither

Less search time outweighed the fee.

Why can a direct client win over two jobs?

  1. Direct work is free
  2. The fee vanishes
  3. The search cost is already paid for the second job
  4. Platforms stop paying

Repeat work needs no new search.

What should you check before moving a client off a platform?

  1. The platform’s current rules
  2. Nothing
  3. The weather
  4. Your font

Some platforms limit contact outside them.

Why avoid depending on one platform?

  1. They never change
  2. They are always cheaper
  3. Rules and fees can change
  4. They are illegal

A single source is a risk.

Summary

  • Count fees and the time spent finding work.
  • Platforms can win on a first job; direct work can win on repeat jobs.
  • Read each platform’s current rules and fees.
  • Do not depend on a single source.

Next lesson

Lesson 20 is the Intermediate project: a month plan with checks.

Questions

Is it allowed to take a platform client elsewhere?

It depends on the platform's current terms, which many platforms set out. Read them before you try, and follow them.

Are platform fees really about 10 per cent?

The 10 per cent in this lesson is made up. Real fees differ and change, so check each platform's current terms.

Which is better for a beginner?

There is no single answer. Many beginners use a platform to start and add direct outreach as they gain samples and confidence.

Progress is saved in this browser.