AdvancedLesson 25 of 306 min read

Contracts in More Depth: An Outline

An outline, not legal advice, of the clauses that matter more as jobs grow (liability, confidentiality, ownership, ending, disputes), with a scan of two sample drafts.

In this lesson you will

  • Name five clauses that matter more on bigger jobs
  • Compare a fair draft with a one-sided one
  • Respond to a client contract
  • Know when to pay a professional

About 25 minutes

The bigger client sends a bigger contract

A small agency asks Dev to proofread a set of brochures, and sends a four-page contract. Dev’s simple one-page agreement from lesson 6 will not do. Larger clients often have their own forms, with clauses that deal with risk, secrecy, ownership and ending the deal. This lesson is an outline, not legal advice. Contract law differs by country, and a real contract of any size deserves a professional’s eye. The aim here is to help you notice what to ask about, so that you do not sign something you do not understand.

Five clauses that matter more as jobs grow

  • Limit of liability. How much you could owe if something goes wrong. Many freelancers ask that it be limited to the fee for the job.
  • Confidentiality. What you must keep private, for how long, and what counts as confidential.
  • Ownership. When the client owns the work, and who owns your tools, templates and methods. Passing ownership once payment is received is a common request.
  • Ending the agreement. How much notice each side must give, and what is paid for work done so far.
  • Disputes and governing law. Which country’s law applies and how disagreements are settled, such as by talking first.

Each of these can be written in many ways, and the exact words matter. That is why a professional should check anything large.

Scan two drafts

The program below reads two made-up agreements. Dev’s draft is a fair one. The agency’s is short and one-sided. The scan uses text patterns for five of the clauses above, and then compares Dev’s liability cap with the exposure the agency draft would create. A text scan cannot understand a contract. It can only show where to look.

import re

terms = {
    "liability cap": r"\bliabilit\w* (is )?(limited|capped)\b|\bcap\w*\b",
    "confidentiality": r"\bconfidential\w*\b",
    "ownership after payment": r"\b(after|once|on) (full )?payment\b",
    "notice to end": r"\b\d+ days?'? notice\b",
    "who decides disputes": r"\bgoverned by\b|\bresolve\w* (any )?disputes?\b",
}
mine = """Liability is limited to the fee paid for the job. Each side keeps the other's
confidential information private. Ownership passes once payment is received in
full. Either side may end the job with 14 days notice. Any disputes will first be
discussed in good faith, and the law of the country named above governs the
agreement."""
theirs = """The contractor accepts unlimited liability for any loss. All work becomes the
client's property on delivery. The client may end the job at any time. The
agreement is governed by the client's local law."""

for label, text in (("mine", mine), ("theirs", theirs)):
    low = " ".join(text.lower().split())
    found = [k for k, pat in terms.items() if re.search(pat, low)]
    print(f"{label}: {len(found)} of {len(terms)} terms found")
    print("  missing:", [k for k in terms if k not in found])

fee = 295
exposure = 5000
print("my cap:", fee, "| their exposure:", exposure)
print("their ask is bigger by:", round(exposure / fee, 1), "times the fee")
print("flags in their draft:", sum(1 for p in ("unlimited liability", "on delivery", "at any time") if p in theirs.lower()))
mine: 4 of 5 terms found
  missing: ['who decides disputes']
theirs: 1 of 5 terms found
  missing: ['liability cap', 'confidentiality', 'ownership after payment', 'notice to end']
my cap: 295 | their exposure: 5000
their ask is bigger by: 16.9 times the fee
flags in their draft: 3

Dev’s draft contains 4 of 5 terms. The missing one is the last, which names how disagreements are decided. That is easy to add. The agency’s draft contains only 1 of 5, with these missing: ‘liability cap’, ‘confidentiality’, ‘ownership after payment’, ‘notice to end’. Its three flags are ‘unlimited liability’, ownership ‘on delivery’ and ending ‘at any time’, each of which favours the client. The exposure line is the most striking. Dev’s cap would be 295, the fee for the job. The agency’s draft makes Dev responsible for any loss, which the program imagines at 5000. That is 16.9 times the fee. For a job worth 295, accepting unlimited liability is a huge risk, and a good reason to ask for a cap or for insurance. This is the kind of mismatch that causes real harm to small freelancers.

How to respond to a client contract

  1. Read the whole thing. Do not skim the clauses at the back.
  2. Mark what you do not understand, and ask the client what it means.
  3. List the points that concern you most, usually liability, ownership and ending.
  4. Propose specific changes in writing, with a one-sentence reason for each.
  5. Keep the signed version and all the emails about it.

Common requests that deserve a careful look

  • Unlimited liability or very large indemnities. Ask for a cap tied to the fee, or for insurance.
  • Ownership on delivery. Ask that it passes on full payment.
  • Non-compete clauses. A ban on working for others can be unreasonable for a freelancer. Ask a professional.
  • Very long payment terms. Waiting months for money is a cash flow problem, as lesson 17 showed.
  • Rights over your tools and past work. Keep ownership of your own templates and methods.

When to pay a professional

Pay a professional to read the contract when the sums are large, when liability is unlimited, when a non-compete or exclusivity clause is involved, or when you are signing a long contract. The cost is usually small beside the risk. Some professional bodies and local services offer free or cheap help to small businesses and freelancers, so look for those in your country.

Common mistake: signing in a hurry

Signing because the client is friendly and in a hurry. Friendly clients also change their minds, and a contract is for the day things go wrong. Read it first, even if it takes a day.

Not legal advice

The agreements are short made-up examples, the scan is a crude text check and the exposure figure is invented. Real contracts need more terms and exact wording. This lesson is an outline and not legal advice. Contract law differs by country, so ask a professional for anything serious.

Take a contract you have been sent, or a template. Underline the five clauses in this lesson, and write one question about each one that you would ask the client.

Practice for this lesson

Check what you learned

Five quick questions. Pick an answer and you will see straight away whether it is right and why.

What does a limit of liability do?

  1. Sets your price
  2. Fixes your hours
  3. Caps how much you could owe if something goes wrong
  4. Ends the job

Many freelancers ask for a cap tied to the fee.

How many terms did the agency’s draft contain?

  1. One of five
  2. Five of five
  3. Four of five
  4. None of five

Only the governing law term was found.

What was wrong with unlimited liability on a 295 job?

  1. It was too short
  2. It exposed Dev to far more than the fee
  3. It was too kind
  4. It was free

The risk dwarfed the fee.

What is a sensible way to respond to a client contract?

  1. Sign at once
  2. Ignore it
  3. Argue by phone only
  4. Propose specific changes with brief reasons

Written, specific changes are clearest.

Is this lesson legal advice?

  1. Yes
  2. No, it is an outline; ask a professional for serious matters
  3. Only for big jobs
  4. Only in one country

Contract law differs by country and changes.

Summary

  • Liability, confidentiality, ownership, ending and disputes matter more as jobs grow.
  • Unlimited liability on a small fee is a large risk.
  • Respond with specific written changes.
  • This is an outline; pay a professional for anything serious.

Next lesson

Lesson 26 shows how to raise your rates.

Questions

Can I just use the client's contract?

You can, but read it carefully and ask for changes. Many clients accept fair changes. For large or unusual terms, ask a professional.

What is an indemnity?

A promise to cover someone's losses in certain situations. Broad indemnities can be risky, so ask a professional before agreeing one.

Is a non-compete clause normal?

It can be, but a broad ban on working for others can be unfair for a freelancer, and the rules differ by country. Ask a professional.

Progress is saved in this browser.