AdvancedLesson 21 of 306 min read

Premium Positioning and Value-Based Pricing

Price the result as well as the effort: compare hourly and value-based fees for three sample jobs, keep your floor, test the client's gain estimate and present a price with confidence.

In this lesson you will

  • Compare hourly and value-based prices
  • Keep your floor in force
  • Test a client’s gain estimate
  • Present a price with confidence

About 25 minutes

The shop owner does not care about your hours

A shop owner asks Dev to write the copy for the shop’s new website. When Dev says the job will take about 20 hours, the owner shrugs: ‘I do not mind how long it takes. I just want customers to buy.’ That sentence changes how a freelancer can price. Until now, this course priced by hours, using a floor. That protects you, and for many jobs it is right. But there is a second idea, value-based pricing, which asks what the result is worth to the client. It needs care, because it can go wrong in both directions. This lesson shows how to use it without fooling yourself or the client.

Hours price the cost, value prices the result

An hourly price answers: what does it cost me to do this? A value-based price answers: what is this worth to the client? When a job takes the same time but creates very different gains, the two answers differ. A leaflet for a tiny charity and a launch page for a busy shop may need similar effort, yet the shop may earn far more from good copy. Charging the same for both ignores that. Charging much more for the shop is fair if the client really expects a large gain.

A safe way to use it

  1. Ask the client what the result is worth to them, in their own numbers: extra orders, saved time, fewer complaints.
  2. Write down the gain they expect, and treat it as their estimate, not a fact.
  3. Choose a modest share of it for your fee, such as a tenth, and check that the fee does not fall below your walk-away price.
  4. Never promise the gain. You can promise your work and your effort, not their sales.
  5. Offer a clear scope, so that the value-based price still buys a defined job.

Compare three jobs

The program below takes three made-up jobs. Each has hours, a gain the client expects in a year, and a share of that gain, 10 per cent, that Dev would ask for. It compares the hourly walk-away price with the value-based price, and takes the higher of the two as the ask. The floor must always hold, because a fee that sounds clever but pays under your floor is a bad deal.

floor = 24.55
# MADE-UP jobs: (job, hours, gain the client expects in a year, share of it asked for)
jobs = [("cafe menu pages", 12, 3000, 0.10),
        ("shop launch copy", 20, 12000, 0.10),
        ("charity leaflet", 8, 400, 0.10)]
for name, hours, gain, share in jobs:
    walk_away = round(hours * floor)
    value = round(gain * share)
    ask = max(value, walk_away)
    print(f"{name}: hourly {walk_away}, value {value}, ask {ask}")
    print(f"  ask is {ask / gain:.0%} of the gain, {ask / hours:.2f} an hour")

# how sure are you about the gain?
fee = 1200
for guess in (12000, 6000, 2400):
    print(f"if the gain is {guess}: fee is {fee / guess:.0%} of it")
cafe menu pages: hourly 295, value 300, ask 300
  ask is 10% of the gain, 25.00 an hour
shop launch copy: hourly 491, value 1200, ask 1200
  ask is 10% of the gain, 60.00 an hour
charity leaflet: hourly 196, value 40, ask 196
  ask is 49% of the gain, 24.50 an hour
if the gain is 12000: fee is 10% of it
if the gain is 6000: fee is 20% of it
if the gain is 2400: fee is 50% of it

For the cafe, the walk-away price is 295 and the value price 300, so the ask is 300, which is 10 per cent of the gain at 25.00 an hour. The two methods agree. For the shop, the picture is quite different. The walk-away price is 491, but the client expects a gain of 12,000, and a tenth of it is 1200. The ask is 1200, paying 60.00 an hour. The client still keeps nine tenths of the gain. For the charity, the expected gain is small, so the value price is only 40, far below the walk-away price of 196. The floor wins, and the ask is 196, which is 49 per cent of the gain. At that point Dev has a choice to make on purpose: charge the floor, give a deliberate discount as a gift to a good cause or decline. What Dev must not do is accept 40 and quietly lose money.

When the gain is a guess

The last lines show the danger. Dev asks the shop for 1,200. If the gain really is 12,000, the fee is 10 per cent of it. If the gain is only half that, the fee is 20 per cent, and if it is a fifth, the fee is 50 per cent of what the shop gains, which may feel steep. Estimates of gain are often hopeful, so check them. Ask where the number comes from. Look at the shop’s current sales. A fee should feel fair to the client in both the good and the poor case.

Where value pricing works best

  • The result is easy to measure, such as sales, leads or hours saved.
  • You have samples or case studies showing similar results, as lesson 23 explains.
  • The client is a business that can see what the work is worth.
  • You are confident in your skill and can explain your approach.
  • The scope is clear, so that you are paid for a result, not for endless extras.

It works less well when results depend on things you do not control, when the client cannot say what the work is worth, or when you are new and have no proof. In those cases, hourly or project prices based on your floor are safer.

Present the price with confidence

Describe the result first and the price second: ‘This copy is designed to turn visitors into customers. The fee is 1,200, covering the launch pages and one round of changes.’ Offer a smaller option too, so that the client chooses between packages, not between yes and no. Never reveal your hours as the reason for the fee unless it is an hourly job, because the client is buying a result.

Common mistake: promising the gain

Claiming that your work will deliver a specific gain, such as ‘this will double your sales’. You cannot control that, and the claim can mislead the client. Promise your work, and talk about their estimate as theirs.

Sample data and no promises

The jobs, gains, shares and fees are made up in sample money. Nobody can promise results from a piece of work, and advertising rules on claims differ by country. This lesson is an outline and not legal or financial advice.

Take a job you might quote. Ask what the result is worth to the client, work out a modest share and compare it with your walk-away price. Then decide your ask.

Practice for this lesson

Check what you learned

Five quick questions. Pick an answer and you will see straight away whether it is right and why.

What does value-based pricing ask?

  1. How many hours it takes
  2. What the result is worth to the client
  3. What rivals charge
  4. What the tax is

It prices the result instead of the effort.

What must always hold when you use value pricing?

  1. A big discount
  2. A promise of results
  3. A secret fee
  4. Your floor

A value price below your floor loses money.

Why did the shop job earn 60 an hour?

  1. The client expected a large gain, so a tenth was large
  2. The job was longer
  3. It was a charity
  4. Tax was lower

A modest share of a big gain exceeded the hourly price.

Why should you check the client’s gain estimate?

  1. They are always exact
  2. They are illegal
  3. Estimates are often hopeful
  4. They set your tax

If the gain is lower, your fee may feel unfair.

What should you never promise?

  1. Your effort
  2. A clear scope
  3. A delivery date you can meet
  4. A specific gain from your work

You do not control the client’s sales.

Summary

  • Hours price the cost; value prices the result.
  • Your floor must always hold.
  • Treat the client’s gain as their estimate and never promise it.
  • Describe the result first and offer options.

Next lesson

Lesson 22 shows how to turn work into productised services.

Questions

Is value-based pricing right for beginners?

It can be, if the result is easy to measure and the scope is clear. Beginners with no proof often do better with hourly or project prices at first.

What share of the gain should I ask for?

There is no fixed share. The example uses a tenth, made up. Choose an amount that feels fair to both sides in a good and a poor case.

Are these numbers real?

No. They are made-up sample numbers in sample money to show the method.

Progress is saved in this browser.